actor most likely to break the suspension of disbelief

[redrobot]

stephen fry or billy connolly get my votes

[original wombat]

Barry Humphries all the way

[redrobot]

why? is it anything to do with the line 'that'll do it''?

[original wombat]

why? is it anything to do with the line 'that'll do it''?

I think it's the only piece of miscasting in all 6 films

[redrobot]

i dont get it. voice seems ok to me. i suppose it cd have been fiercer but then you'd have lost the comedy element.

[original wombat]

just didn't work for me

[redrobot]

that's not very analytical

[siddharth]

No, but it's hypocritical.

[redrobot]

No, but it's hypocritical.

this doesnt make sense

[siddharth]

That was meant for you.

[redrobot]

what a no-sense confusion bomb or the accusation that i'm a hypocrite?

[Elmtree]

I had no problem with any of the actors, certainly they were not broke the suspension of disbelief for me. It was situations-- such as the absurdly long falls, and I couldn't get by the CGI of the white orc. He stood out as a cartoon to me, rather than a character, and given the direction they took the script, he was a vital character. I think they needed a real actor in make up. If you now tell me that all along that WAS a real actor in make up, then he gets my vote

[Otaku-sempai]

Nicholas Cage. What? You didn't specify Middle-earth movies. And Cage was once considered for Aragorn!