I just finished The Sil about two weeks ago.
I was wondering which parts you folks loved the most. And which characters also.
For me, I loved the whole creation-myth, of the two trees, the coming of the Noldor in ME, end of Fingolfin, the Beren-Luthien saga and Nirnaeth Arnodiad the most. Though there are innumerable bits I loved, these were the ones I enjoyed the most. ( Though I didn't like the chapter which describes the whole geography of Beleriand much. It's a bit confusing)
And of characters, I liked Fingolfin, Finrod Felagund,Maedhros, Luthien and Glaurung the most.
What about you?