Luthien because I just finished reading a short story in the Sandman comic concerning Orpheus' disembodied head, which reminds me of the song "Eurydice" that came up earlier tonight on my iPod shuffle, which song reminds me of Luthien.
Ugluk, my roommate and I both are very amused by your platypus quote.
Okay, I vote Maglor because...hmm...I really want coffee, so I'll have to go up to the cafe in the student union to buy some, and they always play weird music up there... Um, there isn't a rule that our votes have to make sense, is there? Well, we can blame my incoherency on the fact that I was awake till 5:30. *yawn*